American Medium Mrs. F.L. Gillette

Potted Fish

Original Recipe

Take out the backbone of the fish; for one weighing two pounds take a tablespoonful of allspice and cloves mixed; these spices should be put into little bags of not too thick muslin; put sufficient salt directly upon each fish; then roll in cloth, over which sprinkle a little cayenne pepper; put alternate layers of fish, spice and sage in an earthen jar; cover with the best cider vinegar; cover the jar closely with a plate, and over this, put a covering of dough, rolled out to twice the thickness of pie crust. Make the edges of paste, to adhere closely to the sides of the jar, so as to make it air tight. Put the jar into a pot of cold water and let it boil from three to five hours, according to quantity. Ready when cold. MAYONNAISE FISH. Take a pound or so of cold boiled fish (halibut, rock or cod), not chop, but cut, into pieces an inch in length. Mix in a bowl a dressing as follows: The yolks of four boiled eggs rubbed to a smooth paste with salad oil or butter; add to these salt, pepper, mustard, two teaspoonfuls of white sugar, and, lastly, six tablespoonfuls of vinegar. Beat the mixture until light, and just before pouring it over the fish, stir in lightly the frothed white of a raw egg. Serve the fish in a glass dish, with half the dressing stirred in with it. Spread the remainder over the top, and lay lettuce leaves (from the core of the head of lettuce) around the edges, to be eaten with it.

Ingredients

grocery
  • 1 of the fish
  • 1 weighing two pounds take a tablespoonful of allspice and cloves mixed
  • 1 little cayenne pepper
  • 1 plate
  • 1 covering of dough
  • 1 pot of cold water and let it boil from three to five hours
  • 4 boiled eggs rubbed to a smooth paste with salad oil or butter
  • 2 teaspoonfuls of white sugar
  • 6 tablespoonfuls of vinegar
  • 1 raw egg
  • 1 glass dish
  • 10 with it

Shop Ingredients

Prices and availability vary by location. We may earn a commission from purchases.

receipt_long

Instructions

  1. 1

    Take out the backbone of the fish; for one weighing two pounds take a tablespoonful of allspice and cloves mixed; these spices should be put into little bags of not too thick muslin; put sufficient salt directly upon each fish; then roll in cloth, over which sprinkle a little cayenne pepper; put alternate layers of fish, spice and sage in an earthen jar; cover with the best cider vinegar; cover the jar closely with a plate, and over this, put a covering of dough, rolled out to twice the thickness of pie crust.

  2. 2

    Make the edges of paste, to adhere closely to the sides of the jar, so as to make it air tight.

  3. 3

    Put the jar into a pot of cold water and let it boil from three to five hours, according to quantity.

  4. 4

    Ready when cold.

  5. 5

    MAYONNAISE FISH.

  6. 6

    Take a pound or so of cold boiled fish (halibut, rock or cod), not chop, but cut, into pieces an inch in length.

  7. 7

    Mix in a bowl a dressing as follows: The yolks of four boiled eggs rubbed to a smooth paste with salad oil or butter; add to these salt, pepper, mustard, two teaspoonfuls of white sugar, and, lastly, six tablespoonfuls of vinegar.

  8. 8

    Beat the mixture until light, and just before pouring it over the fish, stir in lightly the frothed white of a raw egg.

  9. 9

    Serve the fish in a glass dish, with half the dressing stirred in with it.

  10. 10

    Spread the remainder over the top, and lay lettuce leaves (from the core of the head of lettuce) around the edges, to be eaten with it.

Sources & Citations

Sources included so you can explore further.