American Southern Medium mary-randolph

Cod Fish Pie

Soak the fish, boil it and take off the skin, pick the meat from the bones, and mince it very fine; take double the quantity of your fish, of stale bread grated; pour over it as much new milk, boiling hot, as will wet it completely, add minced parsley, nutmeg, pepper, and made mustard, with as much melted butter as will make it sufficiently rich; the quantity must be determined by that of the other ingredients--beat these together very well, add the minced fish, mix it all, cover the bottom of the dish with good paste, pour the fish in, put on a lid and bake it.

Original Recipe

Soak the fish, boil it and take off the skin, pick the meat from the bones, and mince it very fine; take double the quantity of your fish, of stale bread grated; pour over it as much new milk, boiling hot, as will wet it completely, add minced parsley, nutmeg, pepper, and made mustard, with as much melted butter as will make it sufficiently rich; the quantity must be determined by that of the other ingredients--beat these together very well, add the minced fish, mix it all, cover the bottom of the dish with good paste, pour the fish in, put on a lid and bake it.

Ingredients

grocery
  • cod fish
  • stale bread, grated (2x fish we)
  • new milk
  • parsley, minced
  • nutmeg
  • pepper
  • made mustard
  • melted butter
  • good paste

Shop Ingredients

Prices and availability vary by location. We may earn a commission from purchases.

Required Gear

kitchen
Large pot for boiling fish
kitchen
Mixing bowl
kitchen
Baking dish with lid For pie
kitchen
Wooden spoon

* We may earn a commission from these links.

receipt_long

Instructions

  1. 1

    Soak the fish, boil it and take off the skin, pick the meat from the bones, and mince it very fine; take double the quantity of your fish, of stale bread grated; pour over it as much new milk, boiling hot, as will wet it completely, add minced parsley, nutmeg, pepper, and made mustard, with as much melted butter as will make it sufficiently rich; the quantity must be determined by that of the other ingredients--beat these together very well, add the minced fish, mix it all, cover the bottom of the dish with good paste, pour the fish in, put on a lid and bake it.

Sources & Citations

Sources included so you can explore further.